Skip to main content
Buck v. Bell Centennial Resource Collection

State Sterilization Laws

Title

State Sterilization Laws

Description

Banner image: Map of the United States showing states with eugenic sterilization laws.

By the time of U.S. entry into the Second World War, most states—thirty out of forty-eight—had sterilization laws. There was, however, disagreement among experts about which laws counted as properly “eugenic,” and a few early, purely punitive statutes were sometimes omitted from listings. The chart includes all statutes counted by Harry Laughlin (1922) and J. H. Landman (1932) as well as the last two laws passed in South Carolina and Georgia. The chart does not include Puerto Rico, which passed a law in 1937 and repealed it in 1960.

Many states passed, revised, and repealed laws; other enactments were struck down by courts. The chart indicates the first law passed in each state followed by the last action to remove “eugenic” language from state legal codes.

There is no reliable accounting of the number of sterilization operations performed in the United States. The chart is based on a survey done in the 1960s by Julius Paul, described in his unpublished manuscript “Three Generations of Imbeciles Are Enough: State Eugenic Sterilization Laws in American Thought and Practice” (1965). Paul’s study is probably the most thorough and systematic state-by-state investigation of sterilization practices since the 1930s. In it, he assembled data on operations from existing state records, institutional reports, and surveys of officials in all the states. As he reported, accurate totals were extremely elusive. Sometimes surgeries occurred in states with no sterilization laws; in states with laws, sometimes surgeries occurred in hospitals, asylums, and other facilities not governed by those laws. None of these numbers are to be found in official records. All of these factors suggest that the totals appearing in the chart are at best conservative estimates of the total surgeries performed under the rubric of “eugenics.”

Collection Items